With a Mormon candidate for
president, politics and the LDS church have never been brought so close
together. Does religion affect political tendencies? Although there are
exceptions and the church does not endorse any political party, there is a
distinct LDS political identity in the United States. Members of the LDS church
tend to have more conservative views, and there are generally more republicans
within the church.
Political identity is the way people
categorize themselves and how they understand power relationships between
groups (Samuels). There are several factors to be considered when examining the
LDS political identity in the United States. The church’s view on politics is
as such; “While the Church is politically neutral, Mormons are encouraged to
participate in the political process where they live.” (What Role Do Politics
Play in the Lives of Mormons?") However, most Mormons tend to be more
conservative and republican; this can in part be explained by shared values of
church members. Typically Mormons emphasize family, are concerned with their
community, and hold to more traditional values. Shared beliefs and values can
result in a common political identity. Generally conservatives also hold to
traditional values similar to Mormon values.
The idea that similar values in
Mormonism helps to form a political identity can be supported by both
primordialism and constructivism. However, I feel conservatism more accurately
explains the identity. Primordialism is “an approach to understanding identity
which assumes that identities are something people are born with or emerge
through a psychological process at an early age.” (Samuels) Using the
primodialst theory one could explain that most Mormons are raised with
conservative values and beliefs in their home, they are born into it and have
those beliefs engrained in their minds. These values obtained at a young age
explain their political identity of more conservative and republican.
Constructivism is “an approach to understanding identity which assumes
political identifies are malleable and identity is an evolving political
process.” (Samuels) Constructivism helps explain how anything can be politicized
including religion. Constructivism can explain how a convert might adopt Mormon
values, and change their political identity as their values change.
Constructivism also helps to explain the outliers, such as liberal democrat
Mormons. While the majority of Mormons are Republican, there are plenty of
outliers, who hold the same values and beliefs as Mormons; however they have a
different political identity.
According to a survey of more than
1,000 Mormons across the nation conducted by the Pew Research Center’s Forum on Religion and Public Life “The
majority of U.S. Mormons, 66 percent, describe their ideology as conservative,
while 22 percent identify themselves as moderate and 8 percent as liberal.” (POLITICO)
In support to this, 74 percent of registered Mormons are Republican and only 17
percent are Democrats (POLITICO). These numbers show that there is indeed a
Mormon political identity. Shared conservative values are one possible cause
for this political identity. A well-known example of this would be Mormon views
regarding proposition 8 and Gay marriage in general. It is taught in the LDS
church that “marriage between a man and a woman is ordained of God.” (The
Family)
Many
members of the LDS church tend to agree with this, what would be considered “conservative
view” and would vote more conservative on the issue. Another cause for the
Mormon political identity may be loyalty and awareness of Mormon culture.
According to Utah Data Points “A higher proportion of Utah Democrats have a
favorable impression of Mitt Romney (23%) than the approval of Utah Republicans
of Barack Obama’s job performance (5%).” They go on to explain that this is
most likely the result that Mormon democrats share religious experience with
Mitt Romney.” (Monson)
There is a Mormon Political
Identity, although the church does not endorse political views, and there are
certainly outliers; Mormons tend to be conservative and republican. This
identity may be explained by shared values or loyalty to Mormon culture,
regardless of the cause there is a distinct political identity.
Works Cited
"The
Family." : A Proclamation to the World. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Oct. 2012.
<http://www.lds.org/topics/family-proclamation?lang=eng>.
Monson,
Quin. "Utah Data Points." Utah Data Points. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Oct.
2012. <http://utahdatapoints.com/>.
"POLITICO."
POLITICO. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Oct. 2012.
<http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0112/71362.html>.
Samuels,
David. Comparative Politics. New York: Pearson Education, 2013. Print.
"What
Role Do Politics Play in the Lives of Mormons?" What Role Do Politics Play
in the Lives of Mormons? N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Oct. 2012.
<http://www.mormontopics.org/eng/politics?CID=30002>.
I like how you described both sides of the argument for why Mormons have a political identity (using primordialism and constructivism). I also like how you cited many different sources.
ReplyDeleteI feel like you did a great job at describing both the primordialist and constructivist party, but I'm curious as to which argument you believe is more accurate in explaining the LDS political culture. I think that the LDS political culture can be mostly accredited to the primordialist argument because LDS families teach their children at such a young age conservative values that are taught from the gospel.
ReplyDelete