Blog
5: Political Identity
In the current presidential election, it isn’t uncommon
to hear among the run-of-the-mill member of the LDS church that they intend to
vote for Mitt Romney because he is a Mormon; because he is a good person;
because his morals agree with theirs. This kind of thinking is demonstrative of
the distinct political identity that is prevalent in the United States today,
and maybe even throughout the world. In Utah especially this phenomenon
manifest itself among the populace as well in other states where there is a
high concentration of members of the Church. One may contribute this
overarching trend to the politicizing identity of primordialism, which assumes
that political identities are shaped at a very young age due to the values and
beliefs of one’s family; they are fundamental beliefs that shape our opinions
enough that we make political decisions on them (Samuels). Some primordialists
go as far as to say that people are born with these identities. I don’t think
we will go so far as to say that, but simply that childhood predisposes us to
vote one way or another.
Why is this tendency to identify politically so ingrained
into the Mormon culture, one may ask. This can be answered easily. Within the
LDS church, parents are encouraged to teach the religion’s principles to their
children when they are young so they might act on their precepts when they grow
older. Most youth within the church then, grow up being told that “we are all
children of God” and “you have the right to choose for yourself” and the like.
As these ideas are ingrained into their minds and their hearts, children act on
them, and with age, many apply the principles to most aspects of their lives.
The kinship bonds (Samuels) within the church, also
emphasize the common political identity of church members. Most adherents to
Mormonism, have family and friends that help bind them to this religion. Such
connection influences people to develop close emotional and psychological bonds
that “arouse loyalty and provides the basis for the politicization theory”
(Samuels). Political identity finds its roots there, and they may dig deep
easily and often become cemented in one’s life when rooted in such fertile
grounds.
According to research done BYU’s
Center for the Study of Elections and Democracy, and recorded on
Utah Data Points, not only do Republican Mormons approve of and plan to vote
for Mitt Romney in the upcoming election, but 42% of LDS Democrats in Utah,
also approve if him, and are even in favor of him winning the election (Monson).
There we can see a common political identity in agreeing with Mormon ideals
that are visible in his campaign. In a study by Trinity College, statistics
indicated most Mormons have a republican leaning, with 59% of Mormons calling
themselves republican nation-wide, and 90% of those in Utah claiming to
identify themselves as Republican ("Study:
Most Mormons Are Republican." ).
Not only does this suggest similar political identities based on the LDS
religion, but it also intimates that the higher the concentration of members in
one area, the more political monotinicity. These finding s thoroughly support
the supposition that there is a shared political identity within the LDS
church. However, it is important to note that not everyone that is Mormon is a
republican; not all Mormons support Mitt Romney. Though they share common
beliefs, there still ambiguity between members of the LDS church on their
political opinions. However it is a ripe ground to form common political bonds.
Monson, Quin. "Do LDS Democrats Like Mitt Romney?" Utah Date Points. N.p., 22 Aug.
2012. Web. 12 Oct. 2012.
<http://utahdatapoints.com/2012/08/do-lds-dems-like-mitt-romney/>.
Samuels, David J. Comparative Politics.
Minneapolis: Pearson, 2011. Print.
"Study: Most Mormons Are
Republican." UPI.
United Press International, n.d. Web. 12 Oct. 2012.
<http://www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2011/12/14/Study-Most-Mormons-are-Republican/UPI-27481323907182/>.
Very good post overall. I particularly liked your explanations of why the LDS political identity exists, in addition to the evidence confirming that it does exist.
ReplyDelete